THE GAP WIDENS

Two recent events have occasioned this piece. The first was the recently concluded Asian Games in Nagoya, Japan, and the other was the recent visit of an acquaintance to China. Both are indices of the growing gap between China and India, like the backlog of cases in our courts.

I am a sports enthusiast and enjoy watching live events on TV. Far better than silly debates or the violence unleashed by war mongers. Let’s begin with the bare facts for Nagoya.

We are patting ourselves on the back for another under-whelming performance with even the PM congratulating some random athletes for winning bronze medals. Our final tally was 85 medals, of which 21 were gold, giving us a fourth place behind the Asian giants – China, Japan and South Korea. China won 169 gold, 8 times more than us. Also compare this with the last games in 2023. We had then won 28 gold and 106 overall. Our gold tally dropped 25% and overall 20%. In shooting, that was our forte, we dropped from 7 to just 1.

Of our 21 gold, six were in cricket, kabaddi and hockey that are not played by many countries in Asia. Of the 85 medals 9 were from mixed team events of both men and women. Of the 76 gender specific events they were divided equally, 38 each for men and women. Of the individual gold medals the women won half as many as the men. Read the writing on the wall. Let alone becoming a vishwaguru we are from being an Asian tiger.  

It is also worth recalling that japan, Korea and to a lesser extent China were reduced to rubble when World War II ended in 1945. India gained Independence in 1947 from war weary Britain. China became a republic later in 1949. Yet these countries have outstripped India in economic growth and social stability. Even Bangladesh’s GDP is reportedly better than ours. Sri Lanka, Thailand and Vietnam attract far more tourists than we do, even though they have nothing comparable to the Taj Mahal.

Why is India lagging behind? Let’s take the easiest sector first – tourism. I have visited almost every State in India and have been on three foreign trips – the Holy Land (1980), Austria and England (1994) and Italy (2017). The Holy Land was a pilgrimage, not for tourism. It was a police state with citizens living under the shadow the gun. Austria was beautiful, orderly and clean, except for the pet dogs on the pavements. There were several beautiful, but empty, churches and monasteries. 

Like Austria, the English countryside was beautiful, but the Asian dominated urban areas like Wembley were dirty. All of Italy was defaced with graffiti. I was not impressed by the fabled Italian cuisine, though the wine and cheese were good. I also found that, even without purchasing power parity, food and beverages were cheaper than in India. So why would anybody want to visit India?

If I were a foreign tourist looking for a holiday destination, India would not be on my bucket list. Why? Firstly, the filth. Even in Agra, the Taj city, as the train rolls into Agra Fort station early in the morning, one is greeted with a 21 bum salute, of people defecating on the railway tracks. My hometown Kanpur is now considered the Pan Masala capital. It is no sobriquet. It’s disgusting to see people spitting everywhere in public. Common toilets, despite the Swachch Bharat rhetoric, are few and far between. Mounds of garbage are an eyesore in every town and village. Traffic is chaotic and urban roads are indistinguishable from the pot holes. What use are accident prone expressways if urban roads are nonexistent and traffic engineering is abysmal? 

I wonder if we see every tourist as the progeny of the white colonialists, so we need to get back at them. Is that why we cheat and fleece them? The government is the biggest culprit. If an Indian tourist visits the Taj the ticket may be about Rs 20/-. For a foreigner the entry fee could be as much as Rs 500/-. Is this how we welcome them? Then there is the ogling by male chauvinist pigs (MCPs).It is sickening. I also find that other than street food, eating out in an ordinary restaurant that is far from 5-Star is much too expensive. It’s a rip off. So why should foreign tourists visit India? 

Now to the tougher question, the comparison with China. My acquaintance had just returned from his visit with a group. His experiences were an eye-opener. However, there is a caveat. Visitors to China must travel in groups accompanied by a guide to designated places. Hence it is possible that visitors will be showcased only the best parts. Here are his observations.

The country was spotlessly clean. It was well disciplined. The poor were housed in 50 storey apartment buildings. The bullet train was travelling at over 400 kmph but there was no vibration noticeable in his cup of coffee. Another train based on magnetic levitation travelled at 600 kmph, the speed of a commercial jet liner. Amazingly there were no billboards of President Xi Jingping or any other Chinese leader. He felt that China was 100 years ahead of India in technology and at least 25 years ahead of the USA. Small wonder then that Jingping looks suitably bored and expressionless when he visits other countries; unlike our guffawing bear-hugging leader.

Here we go gaga about Vande Bharat trains running at 125 kmph, a shade faster than what Rajdhanis and Shatabdis were running at. We talk of atmanirbhar Bharat but import everything from toys to idols from China. Our trade deals are largely defense procurement contracts, especially from the USA, France and Israel. Even in foreign affairs we have ceded space to our bête noir, Pakistan. Here every municipal councilor or village head has a poster campaign splurging on self-aggrandizement that is conspicuously absent in China.

There is one more glaring difference. China is a professedly atheist country. Here people of all religions are constantly beseeching the gods. Religious processions jam our roads. Blaring loudspeakers drive us mad. We boast of what we euphemistically call “religious tourism”, a thin veneer for State propagation of religions of their choice. Are we suffering from religious diarrhea? I am inclined to believe so. This contrast is also visible in Europe and the Americas. Northern Europe, that is less “religious”, has a higher happy life index and less corruption than Eastern or Southern Europe that are dominated by the Orthodox or Catholic Churches. The same goes for the Americas.

The north is far more developed than the south where dictators and drug lords rule the roost. It is again no coincidence that the south is more Catholic than the north. Has this acted as an opiate for the masses as alleged by Marx?

Coming back to India, if we want to become atmanirbhar and vishwaguru then we need to jettison excessive religiosity. Rats and other rodents destroy one third of our food stocks. We can’t exterminate then because they are “sacred”. Brazil and Texas have the best cattle breeds for both meat and hides. They are of Indian origin – Ongole/ Nelore or American Brahman breeds from the Zebuine strain. Have we missed the boat because of our religious beliefs? The same goes for monkeys that destroy our fruit orchards and standing crops, besides attacking tourists. Do we have the courage to bite the bullet and not allow religion to override good governance?

I do not belong to any political party, though I am left leaning in my social praxis. But I see in hindsight what Jawaharlal Nehru saw with foresight – that organized and militant religion is a major cause of economic and social regression. Corruption and gender disparity also bask in the shadow of religion. The Asian Games results are not an isolated instance.

This article may raise the hackles of some of my “religious” friends. I am not anti-religious. I pray and meditate every day and trust in God’s providence. I also respect all religions. But I believe that we humans are harbingers of our own destiny. We get the leaders that we deserve and reap what we sow. Till then, the gap will keep widening like a yawning chasm.

10 responses to “THE GAP WIDENS”

  1. Edward Sebastian Avatar
    Edward Sebastian

    It is a sincere piece of soul-searching. Facts are presented daringly and openly. I wish I could do something about it. Perhaps I will look around my own surroundings, where I might be able to make a difference. Thank you for being so courageously open and honest.

  2. Lt Col Avinash Sharma (Retd) Avatar
    Lt Col Avinash Sharma (Retd)

    Sir , your observations and penning it down is really a treat to read and worth analysing. Today our media is the biggest culprit in inculcating false sense of pride amongst gen masses , which is far away from the truth. You’ve through your articles have been showcasing the bold blind spot which are purposely kept at th far end of our peripheral sight.
    I’m in sync with you observations n line of thought , my Good wishes to you Sir.

  3. Ashok Avatar
    Ashok

    It is easy to counteract and defeat lies.
    But when lies are offered as misleading myths by the powers that be we are making negligible progress in all fields like sports, manufacturing, science, etcetera.

  4. Vishal Makhani Avatar
    Vishal Makhani

    A blaring-eye opener penned liked a bitter-sweet symphony (blaring being the case if the facts and observations get to one’s conscience and cause an itch.)
    How blatantly have we accepted a fraudulent lifestyle. I believe, uncle, that here one’s resolve, in general, limits him to merely somehow managing to feed his family and himself and somewhere keep up in the rat race. If done honestly, the challenge is to take some portion of the bread home, after having earned it by a day’s toil and the organisers of the splendidly planned rat race gazing at the earned bread with unjustified and unfulfilled hunger.
    Once, the method to do this is learned and accepted by the soul, the on feeding termite, grazing away the book of the constitution, barely makes it to once focus while yet being in the central vision. The debauchery then becomes an unaided and not so bothering concern. The shame is neatly disguised by the system. The train is on fire from the rear end. The passengers conviniently ignore until the fire makes it to their coach. The engine too, unbothered, pulls. This eye-opener can save the fire from spreading, but we passengers need to get up from our seat. I hope, that we do.
    Thanks for holler uncle.

  5. Isaac Gomes Avatar
    Isaac Gomes

    Chhotebhai’s observations on China, especially regarding the yawning gap vis a vis in terms of technological and economic development, are very apt. I don’t know if our social development brains ever considered importing (marrying) Chinese women! Rise in number in this matrimonial alliance will will certainly make two sections of our society extremely happy. First the Church will be elated to witness a great growth in productivity, in Biblical sense. The economists too will be happy in terms of GDP growth, beginning with agriculture (Chinese Communes) and in many other spheres where Chinese steal a march over India. Regarding the hypocrisy of our leaders in religious overdrive, Chhotebhai is spot on.

  6. Isaac Gomes Avatar
    Isaac Gomes

    In my comments, it will be vis a vis China.

  7. Isaac Gomes Avatar
    Isaac Gomes

    If my suggestion is seriously considered, especially by protagonists in the field of sociology and politics, then it would result in much less border tension, salami slicing and avert a possible Indo-China war. The added benefits would be a much better gold medal tally in Olympics, World Championships and of course, in Asian Games (which Chhotebhai has torn to shreds), where at times it might be quite difficult to differentiate between an Indian and a Chinese athlete, thanks to conscious cross-breeding. Just imagine the resultant reduction in defence budget!

  8. Mithun Horo Avatar
    Mithun Horo

    THE GAP WIDENS
    The article above raises an important question: what is more important for the development of a nation—religion, or science, education, discipline, and good governance?
    China’s progress is certainly something we can learn from. Its achievements in cleanliness, technology, rapid transportation, urban planning, employment, and discipline are commendable. If India truly wants to become self-reliant and a global leader, we must focus not merely on slogans, but on real development, education, research, technology, and efficient administration.
    However, it would also be unfair to consider religion entirely as an obstacle to progress. Religion can teach people morality, self-discipline, compassion, and service to humanity. The problem is not religion itself; the problem arises when religious identity overwhelms our conscience, rational thinking, and civic responsibilities.
    I believe that religion should have its place in an individual’s faith and spiritual life, while the governance of a nation should be guided by the Constitution, science, reason, justice, and equality.
    What we need is not a religion-free society, but a society free from religious fanaticism; not opposition to religion, but the development of rational thinking. Temples, mosques, churches, and religious practices are matters of personal faith and freedom. But when it comes to roads, education, healthcare, food, the environment, and administration, the welfare of people should be the highest priority.

    India’s true self-reliance will begin when we learn to value reason over emotion, competence over identity, and meaningful work over empty slogans.
    Mithun Horo,South Dinajpur

    1. Isaac Gomes Avatar
      Isaac Gomes

      Very well-said. One of the reasons for China’s rapid strides in almost all spheres is its Dictatorship which does not allow an inch for debate, discussion, and typical derailment by the Opposition which we witness in a democracy like India. Here the Opposition thinks its main responsibility is to pull down the incumbent government and gain power by hook or crook. Example the hullabaloo created by the then Opposition over 2G Scam to dislodge the UPA government in the name of bringing ‘Acchey Din’ which is yet to come!

  9. Raj Avatar
    Raj

    15 countries were there. We have come a long way from 1 gold only in hockey ! A fall in medals is there. But I am positive not a defeatist . We are still a younger nation . Compare European nations who were only 79.
    Sportsmen cannot be made on empty stomachs it requires finances and a host of other issues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha