DARK CLOUDS OVER ARUNACHAL

Arunachal Pradesh means the “Land of the Rising Sun”, because, being in the eastern most part of India, it is the first part of the county to be kissed by the rays of the rising sun. But now sinister dark clouds hover over Arunachal. Why?

This 6th March thousands of Arunachalis in different parts of the State organised peaceful prayer rallies in protest against the impending revival or implementation of the Arunachal Pradesh Freedom of Religion Act (APFRA) 1978. This included a rally organised by the Christian Forum of Bordumsa at St Joseph’s Church, Rajanagar, Changlang district. An even bigger rally of about 20,000 was held in the Arunachal capital of Itanagar, where several former Ministers also participated.

It may be recalled that this Act was passed in 1978, but it gathered dust for 46 years until it was resurrected by a petition filed in the Guwahati High Court seeking framing of rules for implementation of the aforesaid Act. I have a personal connect with Arunachal because my wife, Meera, was working there as a government teacher for some years circa 1980. Together we had re-visited the state in 2018 for the death anniversary of my former colleague Prembhai, whom my wife was instrumental in bringing to Arunachal.

A copy of this Act was given to me in 1990 by former Arunachal M.P., Bakin Pertin, who was then a member of the National Minorities Commission, during my first tenure as the National President of the All India Catholic Union.

I was also present at Prembhai’s Banderdewa Ashram when Sri Pema Khandu, Chief Minister of Arunachal, announced to thunderous applause that the APFRA would be repealed in the very next session of the State legislature. That was 7 years ago. Now, contrary to what the CM had then solemnly announced, this Act is seeking to be implemented through the back door. The modus operandi is similar to what happened in neighbouring Manipur State two years ago.

At that time the Scheduled Tribe Demand Committee of Manipur for Meteis had filed a plea in the same High Court seeking Scheduled Caste status for the non-tribal Meteis, who are mostly Hindus. Interestingly, Hinduism came to Manipur just a couple of centuries ago, preceded by Islam via Bengal.

We know all too well what happened in Manipur after the High Court order. The State went up in flames causing a deep ethnic divide that resulted in the murder and rape of hundreds of Manipuris and the displacement of thousands of tribal Kukis. But as the Prophet Hosea says, “If you sow the wind, you will reap a whirlwind” (Hos 8:7). It resulted in the Chief Justice of the High Court being summarily removed. Manipur Chief Minister N. Biren Singh was also ultimately booted out, placing the State under President’s Rule. It was widely believed that Biren Singh was brazenly partisan. He was likened to Emperor Nero fiddling while Rome burnt.  

Will Arunachal go the Manipur way? Perish the thought. There is still time to learn from recent errors. The Arunachal Christian Forum submitted a Memorandum to the CM on 24/11/2024 emphatically stating that Arunachal was a peaceful State and there were no cases of forced conversion. Then why this act? Because of its ambiguous wording it had the potential to be misused or abused. This Memorandum was signed by the Forum President Tarh Miri and its General Secretary James Techi Tara.

The North East Catholic Research Forum also submitted a Memorandum to the CM of Arunachal on 12/2/2025 expressing similar concerns. It was signed by John Shilshi IPS (R) and 45 top academicians and lay leaders from across the North East. The Act is ostensibly meant to protect tribal traditions. The reality is that the Catholic Church in particular has been in the forefront of actively promoting, not just protecting, such traditions. I recall that 44 years ago my wife was assisting Rev Kulandai in preparing an initial English-Nishi dictionary for the people, as it was one of the major tribal languages. Notably there are 26 major tribes and over 100 sub-tribes in Arunachal.

In the light of the above it is hoped that the Arunachal government will not take any foolhardy step that could jeopardise the peaceful co-existence of the Arunachali people, by trying to ram this Act down their throats. I appeal to the CM and all the legislators to rise above party lines or ideologies, in the best interest of the State and the nation.

11 responses to “DARK CLOUDS OVER ARUNACHAL”

  1. Rajveer Samuel Avatar
    Rajveer Samuel

    Dicey atmosphere, unpredictable situation, hope good sense prevails.

  2. Isaac Gomes Avatar
    Isaac Gomes

    Chhotebhai has witten a very deeply thought out article banking on his rich knowledge of the North-east. The concerns expressed are quite justified . With reference to the last paragraph, how many of our politicians are really bothered about the best interests of their states and the nation? The interests of the two cannot be diametrically opposite and must always be complementary.

  3. ANAND IMS Avatar
    ANAND IMS

    Thank you Chotebhai for this well researched article. You have thrown light on the background of the present day crisis. Let us hope and pray earnestly that good will reigns.
    It is also an opportunity for all the Christians to give away their differences and unitedly fight against evil forces determined to cause unrest in the peaceful society of Arunachal.

  4. John S Shilshi Avatar
    John S Shilshi

    Timely and to the point. Wonder why an act that was put on a back burner for many years suddenly found pushers. No legislation with divisive agenda must find place in today’s society. Harmony, after all, is the name of the game.
    Well written!!

  5. Fr. A. Sebastian Avatar

    I would like to thank you for this thought provoking reflection. Who are those that seem to be behind this agenda? Shall we also reflect on the reasons, if any, that seem to support this act and address those reasons as well? May the Holy spirit lead us.

  6. Rajiv Edgar Avatar
    Rajiv Edgar

    Awesome ,thought provoking article, very precise, kudos to Chotebhai for this well researched article .🙏

  7. Isaac Gomes Avatar
    Isaac Gomes

    As per Census 2001, Arunachal Pradesh had a Christian population of 205,548 persons (18.72%). In 2011 census Christian population showed an encouraging increase to 418,732 persons (30.26%). After that the central government hasn’t conducted any census, ostensibly due to Covid-19. We don’t know what the outcome will be in the new census (likely in 2026?). It is quite likely the powers-that-be are wary of a possible upward trend and wish to project this rise as a result of Conversion by “misrepresentation, force, undue influence, coercion, allurement (promise of free education, employment, better lifestyle or divine pleasure) by any other fraudulent means.” Therefore, it’s possible some strings are being pulled in Guwahati. It must be noted Arunachal Pradesh does not having its own High Court. It’s high time it had one.

    With the enactment of the State of Mizoram Act, 1986 ( Act 34 of 1986 ) and the State of Arunachal Pradesh Act, 1986 ( Act 69 of 1986), the States of Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh attained statehood on 20.2.1987. By the State of Mizoram Act, 1986, from the appointed day, common High Court for the States of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura and Mizoram called the High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura and Mizoram came into being. Under the State of Arunachal Pradesh Act, 1986, from the appointed day, i.e, 20.2.1987, a common High Court for the State of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh came into being.

    The Principal Seat of the Gauhati High Court is at Guwahati, Assam. Apart from the Principal Seat, the High Court has 3 (three) outlying Benches, viz, Kohima Bench for the State of Nagaland (established on 1.12.1972), Aizawl Bench for the State of Mizoram (established on 5.7.90) and Itanagar Bench for the State of Arunachal Pradesh (established on 12.8.2000). The Gauhati High Court occupied a unique position of being a common High Court of seven States of North East India, till 23.03.2013, the date of the functioning of separate High Courts in Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura.

  8. Isaac Gomes Avatar
    Isaac Gomes

    In view of my above comments on the last two Censuses, no wonder Arunachal Pradesh Freedom of Religion Act (APFRA), 1978, having been put in cold storage for 46 years, is being dug out of its grave now. By now this bill should have been withdrawn just like the three Farmers’ Bills. PM Modi had to publicly apologize to the farmers, thanks to very strong farmers agitation and international reaction.

    It’s high time Christians of Arunachal Pradesh with strong support from its sister states, make the Arunachal Pradesh State Government / Assembly withdraw the Bill.

    It’s highly likely that some strings are being pulled in Guwahati by HB & Co!

    The million dollar question is who is the petitioner who raked up the issue in September 2024, in the Itanagar Bench of the Gauhati High Court? How could the judge, after hearing the petition, order the government to frame rules for the anti-conversion law within six months, knowing full well about the Central Government/ Parliament’s withdrawal/roll back of the three Farm Laws? It’s good Christians of Arunachal Pradesh were alert to Manipur High Court-like surreptitious move and have decided to take the bull by its horns.

  9. Mary C Avatar
    Mary C

    Thank you for the article .

  10. Mathew M.V. Avatar

    Hi
    The well studied article is to more information and action.We have to support the people of Arunachal with prayers and with ideas.We can think all are for positive action.

  11. Roshan Avatar
    Roshan

    Very well researched and connects to the emotional core of this topical issue. Written with deep understanding and personal connect.

Leave a Reply to Fr. A. Sebastian Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *